The choice between skid steer loader tracks vs wheels is an equipment decision for construction and earthmoving projects. Wheeled skid steers have been around longer than track loaders. Operators have decades of experience running these machines. This historical advantage doesn’t automatically make wheels the better option for every situation.
Wheeled Skid Steers
Wheeled skid steers offer a budget-friendly option to operators who want speed and efficiency. These machines cost 15-20% less than tracked alternatives, making them appealing to cost-conscious businesses and rental customers.
The economic benefits extend well beyond the purchase price. Tire replacements cost nowhere near as much as tracks, and basic air-filled options start at just $100 each. Depending on working conditions, a complete set of tires lasts between 600-1,000 hours. This durability leads to reduced operating costs over time.
These machines shine on hard surfaces such as concrete, asphalt, or compacted soil. Operators can pivot quickly and direct tight spaces with precision. The machines run at faster ground speeds than tracked models, which proves invaluable when time matters most.
Warehouse operations, urban construction sites, and indoor projects benefit from wheeled skid steers’ floor protection capabilities. These machines also minimize damage to landscaped surfaces that tracked equipment might destroy.
The speed, agility, and cost advantages of wheeled skid steers make them a smart choice for work on developed surfaces. This is true especially for businesses that need to boost both productivity and profits.
Track Loaders
Track loaders excel where regular machines fail. These powerful machines use tracks instead of wheels, which creates a lower center of gravity and increases stability on tough surfaces.
Their broader weight distribution helps them “float” rather than sink on uneven terrain, inclines, and soft ground. The impressive ground-to-surface contact lets them work quickly in mud, sand, snow, and loose gravel without getting stuck.
These machines offer more than just mobility advantages. Operators experience smoother rides that reduce fatigue during long shifts. The enhanced stability and traction also boost their lifting capacity.
Track loaders shine in specific industries. Construction teams rely on them for demolition, dozing, land clearing, and paving on rough surfaces. Farm operators value their versatility in different conditions, including snow removal work.
Rubber tracks make these machines perfect for sensitive surface work by spreading weight more evenly than wheels, which protects turf and soil. This blend of stability, power, and surface protection makes track loaders essential when safety matters most, especially in bad weather or difficult terrain.
Over-the-Tire Tracks
Over-the-tire (OTT) tracks provide an ingenious solution to operators who want the best of both wheels and tracks. These attachable systems can transform a wheeled machine into a tracked one by wrapping around existing skid steer tires in just 20-30 minutes.
OTT tracks significantly boost traction in tough conditions. They distribute weight across a larger surface area and improve flotation, which makes operation easier on soft ground, snow, and ice. The wider footprint reduces ground pressure and prevents damage to sensitive surfaces like lawns and cultivated areas.
Two main types of OTT tracks exist – rubber and steel – each with its own purpose. Rubber tracks work great on turf, asphalt, and driveways while reducing vibration for smoother operation. Steel tracks prove their worth in extreme conditions like mud, ice, and steep slopes.
OTT tracks offer practical economic advantages beyond their versatility. Operators can attach or remove them as needed instead of buying a separate track loader. While they need upfront investment, these tracks protect tires from punctures and extend their life.
Businesses working on different projects and terrains will find OTT tracks to be the perfect middle-ground solution. They combine a wheel’s speed with a track’s all-terrain capabilities in one adaptable machine.
So… Is A Skid Steer Loader Better With Tracks Or Wheels?
Your skid steer’s wheel or track choice depends on your job needs, work conditions, and budget. Wheeled skid steers work best for operators who need speed and maneuverability on hard, developed surfaces. On top of that, their lower price tag and minimal maintenance costs make them a smart choice for many businesses.
Skid Steer Loader FAQs
Are tracks or wheels better for a skid steer loader?
The choice between tracks and wheels depends on your specific job requirements and working conditions. Tracks are better for uneven terrain, soft ground, and wet conditions, offering improved stability and traction. Wheels are ideal for hard, flat surfaces, providing speed and maneuverability at a lower cost.
What are the advantages of tracked skid steers?
Tracked skid steers offer superior stability, better performance on challenging terrain, improved flotation on soft ground, and enhanced lifting capacity. They also provide a smoother ride for operators and cause less damage to sensitive surfaces due to their weight distribution.
Are wheeled skid steers more cost-effective?
Yes, wheeled skid steers are generally more cost-effective. They have a lower initial purchase price, typically 15-20% less than tracked alternatives. Additionally, tires are significantly cheaper to replace than tracks, contributing to lower long-term operating expenses.
What are over-the-tire (OTT) tracks, and when should I use them?
OTT tracks are attachments that wrap around existing skid steer tires, combining the benefits of both wheels and tracks. They’re ideal when you need increased traction in challenging conditions or want to reduce ground pressure on sensitive surfaces. OTT tracks offer flexibility for operators working across diverse terrains without needing two separate machines.
How do I choose between a wheeled and tracked skid steer for my project?
Consider your working conditions, project requirements, and budget. Wheeled skid steers are best for hard surfaces, speed, and cost-efficiency. Tracked models excel in challenging terrain and provide better stability. For versatility, consider a wheeled skid steer with the option to add OTT tracks. It’s also recommended to rent both types to test performance in a specific working environment before a decision.
